When someone doubts our abilities, it can shake our confidence and make us question ourselves. But sometimes, being underestimated can motivate us to work harder and accomplish things others thought were impossible. Organizational scientist Samir Nurmohamed studies what he calls the “underdog effect.” He explains why criticism and rejection can sometimes become powerful sources of motivation, and how we can harness this effect in our own lives. Then, on Your Questions Answered, social scientist Ben Rogers returns to respond to listeners’ comments about the stories we tell about our lives, and how these narratives shape our sense of meaning.
How should we handle criticism that comes not from strangers and bosses, but from our own friends and family? And how can we offer feedback to friends and family in a way that motivates rather than demoralizes them? We explore these questions with Samir Nurmohamed in a conversation for Hidden Brain+ subscribers. That episode is titled “What Do They Know?” If you’re not yet a subscriber, you can access that conversation with a free seven-day trial at support.hiddenbrain.org or apple.co/hiddenbrain.
Episode illustration by Getty Images for Unsplash+
Transcript
The transcript below may be for an earlier version of this episode. Our transcripts are provided by various partners and may contain errors or deviate slightly from the audio.
SHANKAR VEDANTAM: This is Hidden Brain. I'm Shankar Vedantam. In the early 1960s, a young writer poured his heart and soul into a comic novel set in New Orleans. A Confederacy of Dunces was about the misadventures of a lazy, philosophical man who still lived with his mother. But when John Kennedy Toole sent his manuscript out to publishers, the response was crushing. Editors told him the story was pointless, that it lacked structure, that it would not sell without major revisions. For the novelist, these rejections were a major blow. He fell into despair. Eventually, he abandoned his efforts to publish the novel and began to drink heavily. He told friends he felt humiliated. In 1969, at age 31, John Kennedy Toole died by suicide. His novel seemed destined to vanish, another unpublished manuscript gathering dust. But the story didn't end there. His mother, Thelma, could not bear the idea that her son's work would be forgotten. She took the manuscript to the novelist Walker Percy and begged him to read it. He was certain he would hate it, but unwilling to reject a grieving mother, he reluctantly agreed to have a look. As he started to turn the pages, Walker Percy realized that he was wrong. The book was brilliant. In 1980, 11 years after the author's death, A Confederacy of Dunces was finally published. A year later, it won the Pulitzer Prize, which Thelma Toole accepted on her son's behalf. What had been dismissed as a pointless story that could not be published became one of the most celebrated novels of the 20th century. All of us have felt the sting of negative feedback at one time or another. In John Kennedy Toole's case, this feedback was soul-crushing. But does it always have to be this way? Can the sting of doubt and the bite of criticism ever be our friends? This week on Hidden Brain, and in a companion episode on Hidden Brain Plus, how to turn the rejections of the world into fuel. SHANKAR VEDANTAM: Think back to a time when someone doubted you. It might have been a teacher who told you that you would never amount to much, or a boss who dismissed an idea that you'd spent weeks developing. All of us know that negative feedback can be hurtful. A single comment from someone we respect can linger in our minds for days. An offhand remark from a friend can wound us deeply. Criticism and rejection can sting and send us into downward spirals of self-doubt. At the University of Pennsylvania's Wharton School, Samir Nurmohamed has studied these moments. He's discovered something curious. Sometimes, being dismissed by the world has the opposite effect on us. Samir Nurmohamed, welcome to Hidden Brain. Samir Nurmohamed: Thanks so much for having me. SHANKAR VEDANTAM: Samir, I want to take us back to 1991, um, to a high school quarterback in San Mateo, California. Now, this young athlete would go on to be very famous, but it's not something you would have predicted if you'd met him in 1991. Who was this athlete, and what was happening at this high school? Samir Nurmohamed: So yeah. So Tom Brady was a quarterback for his high school junior varsity team in Junipero Serra High in San Mateo, California. And he was, you know, the quarterback for the team, and there was nothing really that stood out about him compared to other quarterbacks around the country. You know, a lot of people were getting recruited heavily. Brady wasn't the same way. So as a sophomore, he started, uh, quarterback for the junior varsity team, and he actually started performing pretty well in this wide-open offense. But at the end of the season, the coach told him that he'd have to work much harder in the weight room, which is not uncommon at this stage. Uh, Tom Brady, though, you know, took it to the extreme in a way, and he goes home, and he convinces his parents to find a personal trainer. SHANKAR VEDANTAM: Wow ... Samir Nurmohamed: as well as an off-season quarterback coach. SHANKAR VEDANTAM: Oh, wow. As, as a sophomore in high school. Samir Nurmohamed: As a sophomore in high school, believe it or not. And the, his coach famously said, you know, "I don't think we'll ever have to tell him to work harder again." SHANKAR VEDANTAM: So he had a somewhat modest record at, uh, at the high school level. He, he goes on to play football for the University of Michigan, but he doesn't have immediate success there either. Samir Nurmohamed: No, he doesn't. So Michigan had just come off, you know, winning the national championship and had these other quarterbacks such as, uh, Scott Dreisbach and Brian Griese, and then Tom Brady comes afterwards, but he's not the starter in the same way. He's competing for the job. Hmm. Um, so Lloyd Carr, who's the coach who's, you know, led Michigan to success, Brady goes to him and is like, "You know what? I, I think I wanna transfer. I wanna leave the University of Michigan." And he's thinking about transferring back home to California. SHANKAR VEDANTAM: And what happens? Does he do so? Samir Nurmohamed: Um, no, he, he does not, thankfully, um, as someone who graduated from the University of Michigan. Um, but in the same way that Brady, you know, hired a personal trainer while in high school, um, he does something pretty extreme at the time. He actually goes and seeks out a sports psychologist- SHANKAR VEDANTAM: Hmm ... Samir Nurmohamed: to help him kind of mellow out in, in college. And from that psychologist, Tom Brady learns to worry less about how other quarterbacks on the roster are doing and more about himself. SHANKAR VEDANTAM: So he signs up for the NFL draft in, uh, 2000, um, and I wanna play you some excerpts from the pre-draft scouting report on the young quarterback. Scouting Report audio: poor build, skinny, lacks great physical stature and strength Lacks mobility and ability to avoid the rush, lacks a really strong arm, can't drive the ball downfield, does not throw a really tight spiral System-type player who can get exposed if forced to ad-lib. And gets knocked down easily. SHANKAR VEDANTAM: So that is not a stellar scouting report and, and the draft reflected this, Samir. For our non-US audiences, um, the better the football player, the earlier they get picked in the draft. When was Tom Brady selected? Samir Nurmohamed: Famously in the sixth round, the 199th pick overall in the draft. SHANKAR VEDANTAM: I understand that six other quarterbacks were selected ahead of him, Samir? Samir Nurmohamed: Yeah, absolutely. So he was, he was drafted behind other quarterbacks that we haven't heard of before, probably you and me, um, who even, you know, watch football. Um, it's folks like Giovanni Carmazzi and Spurgeon Wynn. SHANKAR VEDANTAM: So tell me the rest of that story. Where does it go from there, Samir? Samir Nurmohamed: Yeah, so I mean, Tom Brady had a bit of a chip on his shoulder. Um, he was, you know, not the starting quarterback for New England. He actually wasn't even the backup or the third string. He was listed as the fourth string quarterback, so when the Patriots needed a backup for their quarterback, they signed someone else as a free agent from the Miami Dolphins, refusing to promote Tom Brady. SHANKAR VEDANTAM: Now, that story doesn't end there, of course. Uh, what happens that following season? Samir Nurmohamed: So he wanted to get better. Um, just like he did in high school and college, he worked tirelessly with the, you know, the staff around him. So he worked tirelessly with the New England quarterbacks coach. Um, but you know, during that summer, during that training camp in August 2001, uh, the quarterback coach has a heart attack. And because of that late date, the c- head coach of the team, Bill Belichick, had to take over the quarterback coach's duties. And he had to work with Tom Brady. And Belichick started working with Brady, and he came away pretty impressed. So on the eve of the 2001 season, he announced that Brady, and not the person they signed from Miami, would back up Bledsoe. SHANKAR VEDANTAM: And early in that, in that season, um, the, the quarterback for the, for the Patriots, uh, Drew Bledsoe, got injured, uh, paving the way for Tom Brady to, to start. Samir Nurmohamed: Exactly. I mean, it was a, I, I remember that press conference. People were wondering, like, "Who is this guy, essentially taking over for the great Drew Bledsoe?" And Bill Belichick announces that Brady would start against the Indianapolis Colts, and at that press conference, Belichick told reporters, "I don't think th- I'll be up here standing in 10 weeks talking about all the problems that Tom Brady had." And then in the next week, the Patriots thump the Colts 44 to 13. SHANKAR VEDANTAM: So Brady goes on to win the Super Bowl that year, which is kind of an unbelievable story, but even more than that, between 2001 and, and 2020, I, I believe he appeared in 10 Super Bowls and won seven times. I mean, he was so successful that Sports Illustrated called him a caricature of success. I, I mean, his record is simply unbelievable, Samir. Samir Nurmohamed: Yeah, I mean, it's unbelievable, especially when you think about where he came from, right? So here was someone that, like we talked about at the scouting combine for the draft, you know, was thought of as too slow, didn't have the right throwing motion, um, was awkward on the field, unimpressive, and yet he's considered not only the greatest quarterback of all time, but the, maybe one of the greatest football players of all time. SHANKAR VEDANTAM: And perhaps one of the most remarkable things about the story, Samir, is that even after he left the New England Patriots, uh, Tom Brady continued to succeed at a very high level. Samir Nurmohamed: Some critics thought that, you know, Tom Brady was a product of the system that he was in, being in an organization like the New England Patriots, and being with Bill Belichick. So Tom Brady famously left to go join the Tampa Bay Buccaneers when New England basically said that we wanna move on from him, and Tom Brady goes on to win another Super Bowl, becoming one, one of the oldest players to ever win one and win the MVP. SHANKAR VEDANTAM: You know, i- in the course of his career, Brady was compared to a number of people, but, but he had a great, uh, competitor in, in Peyton Manning, who famously, I believe, was taken the first in the NFL draft when it was, uh, when it was his turn to be drafted. So in some ways you had a player who was taken very high, where there were very high expectations of, and a player who was taken very low, who had, people had terrible expectations of him. And, and it's so curious and interesting that these two people became, you know, significant competitors in the course of their careers. Samir Nurmohamed: Absolutely, you know, Peyton Manning comes from a football family. His father was an NFL star. Um, he was a top recruit for Tennessee, drafted number one overall, famously broke all sorts of records, in the NFL, and won Super Bowls with the Indianapolis Colts. So you've got him as essentially the favorite, but then you've got Tom Brady on the other hand, that people discounted and wrote off. And Tom Brady, in many ways, ended up having the more successful career, even though both of them achieved high levels of success. SHANKAR VEDANTAM: And I still remember some matches that they played, uh, you know, a- and the, the thing I always remember when, when, when Tom Brady was playing, was that you simply could never write him off. You know, no matter how bad things looked for New England, if, if Brady was the quarterback, you simply could not write them off, and in some ways, that is the, the story of his life, which is that he had been written off so often and came back so often, that even when he was really down, people started to say, "You know, this is not someone whom you can underestimate." Samir Nurmohamed: Yeah, it makes you wonder how those early experiences that Tom Brady had, you know, played into that success for when those moments were tough and people wrote him off, that he could kind of draw on that well of experience and basically try to still be motivated and perform at a high level. And I think if you look at a lot of the things that football scouts measure, Peyton Manning comes out, you know, in terms of arm strength and height and throwing motion and so forth. But Tom Brady had a lot of these un- intangibles that you don't measure in the same way. SHANKAR VEDANTAM: Talk about how he never forgot the lean years, never forgot the rejections. He, he never forgot the way he had been dismissed. He actually used all of that to his advantage. Samir Nurmohamed: Absolutely. So Tom Brady, you know, still talks about it to this day, you know, being drafted as the 199th pick overall. Um, he quotes people, you know, even during the peak of his career, who doubted his ability to win another Super Bowl or perform at a high level. Um, he never thought of himself as the favorite. He always continued to think of himself as the underdog. SHANKAR VEDANTAM: I wanna play a clip of Tom Brady talking about the effects that early rejection had on him. Uh, this clip is from an interview around the time that people were asking if he was ready to retire. Tom Brady: ...got drafted in the sixth round. Mm-hmm. You know, no one thought I'd make the team. Interviewer: So that drives you. Tom Brady: You know? Yeah, it still does. I mean, I think now, now it's like, "Wait a minute, now you guys want me to stop playing? No, this is when, this is when I'm having fun." SHANKAR VEDANTAM: In some ways, I can still hear that kid from that high school in San Mateo, Samir. Samir Nurmohamed: I think so. I think that's ultimately what, what drove him, and he still remembers that experience. He still remembers that moment, and he still practices as if he's that same player on the high school team or that same person in college or that backup quarterback or even fourth stringer on the New England Patriots before, you know, he got all the success and became the greatest quarterback of all time. SHANKAR VEDANTAM: When people doubt us, it can make us feel like the wind has been knocked out of our sails. Sometimes it can make us want to give up on our goals altogether. But at other times, those very same doubts can cause us to accomplish great things. When we come back, we explore a great puzzle in human motivation. You're listening to Hidden Brain. I'm Shankar Vedantam. SHANKAR VEDANTAM: This is Hidden Brain. I'm Shankar Vedantam. There are moments in all of our lives when someone doubts us: a teacher, a boss, a parent, even a stranger. But doubt doesn't always land the same way. Sometimes it crushes us. Other times, it lights a fire we didn't know we had. Motivation, it turns out, is complicated. At the University of Pennsylvania's Wharton School, Samir Nurmohamed studies what makes people rise to the occasion. Samir, when you were in graduate school working on your dissertation, you came across some research on self-fulfilling prophecies. Describe that research to me. Samir Nurmohamed: So the whole idea of the self-fulfilling prophecy is that when others have expectations of us, we try to meet those expectations. So for example, there's this idea called the Pygmalion effect. And when others have high expectations of us, oftentimes it could be people in our lives, whether it's, you know, a teacher or a manager, uh, for example, we as a newcomer to that organization are, they form our expectations, they shape our expectations, and our confidence level rises and we're more motivated, and we perform better. SHANKAR VEDANTAM: Hmm. And this works in reverse as well, right? Give people a bad reputation, and they'll find ways to live up to them. Samir Nurmohamed: Absolutely. So there's, on the flip side of the Pygmalion effect, there's what's called the Golem effect, and the Golem effect is similarly about anticipating poor performance. So for example, there have these, been these really incredible studies done in military settings, showing that if commanders have low expectations of their cadets, their cadets actually perform worse, because they basically, their commanders are anticipating poor performance, and those expectations can be transferred over to the cadets directly, but also indirectly. So for example, the, the supervisors may not give the cadets the same amount of time or resources or opportunities to succeed. SHANKAR VEDANTAM: So you decided to study this phenomenon for yourself, Samir. Uh, one of your first studies looked at employees at a company. You examined what happened to people when they felt underestimated. Tell me about this work. Samir Nurmohamed: I was interested in this idea in the field in organizations to see whether it plays out, and we surve- I surveyed, you know, 1,000 employees in this consumer packaged goods company and found out, you know, to the extent that they believe that they were underestimated by others. SHANKAR VEDANTAM: Hmm. Samir Nurmohamed: Um, and what I really like about this context is that it gets people right at the early stages of them joining the company. So people are still forming their, their sense of, you know, how they're gonna do on the job. But also, other people don't have perfect insight into how well these people will do. SHANKAR VEDANTAM: So these are people whom you're basically asking, you know, do other people underestimate you, do people overestimate you, or do people estimate you correctly? Samir Nurmohamed: Exactly, yeah. We're seeing how they're, how they're perceived by other people. SHANKAR VEDANTAM: So I’m curious what you found Samir, Of the people who felt like they had been underestimated by others, how did that affect their performance? Samir Nurmohamed: So I found that people who saw themselves as underestimated by others, they actually performed better in their jobs as rated by their supervisors. SHANKAR VEDANTAM: And, and did you have an understanding of why this was happening? I mean, it seems paradoxical. Samir Nurmohamed: Yeah. It was kind of peculiar 'cause, you know, given the prior research on the self-fulfilling prophecy, um, so one thing I wanted to do was, you know, understand this a bit more, so I ended up doing follow-up studies in the, in the lab to better understand the mechanisms through which this happens. SHANKAR VEDANTAM: So you've used the phrase the underdog effect to describe this phenomenon. Um, explain where this term comes from, Samir. Samir Nurmohamed: Yeah, so the underdog term comes from this idea that you perceive that others don't believe you can succeed, and this can come from people that you're close to or people that are more distal from you. It can be- come from people within your organization if you're in a company or people outside of your organization. Hmm. Um, so it's a, it's a very broad definition. SHANKAR VEDANTAM: So an underdog is basically someone whom other people widely perceive to not be likely to win or to succeed. Samir Nurmohamed: Exactly, and I think the key here is that it's, it's perceptual. It's subjective. It doesn't have to be true. SHANKAR VEDANTAM: So in your follow-up work on the underdog effect, did you find that your work at this first company was a fluke? Did you find the same results elsewhere? Samir Nurmohamed: Yeah, so I, you know, did these studies a- in additional settings where we had more control over being able to find out the explanation for this, and what I found was, you know, a similar effect in each of these contexts, so that when people were facing underdog expectations, they were performing better in terms of their effort. And what I started to unpack and find is that there was a unique reason why people were motivated. They wanted to prove others wrong. You know, this idea of reactance is, you know, one of the theories in social psychology that's talked about, and it's basically how you act in response to threats to your freedom and autonomy. And I think that's part of what's going on here. SHANKAR VEDANTAM: You also talk about something called self-enhancement theory. Uh, unpack that idea. Samir Nurmohamed: Yeah, so self-enhancement theory is all about this idea that people have a fundamental need to see themselves in positive ways. SHANKAR VEDANTAM: Hmm. Samir Nurmohamed: And they strive to protect themselves from evaluations that undermine these positive beliefs. SHANKAR VEDANTAM: So when someone dismisses you or thinks that you're not gonna be very good, there's a part of you that sort of says, you know, "Let me look for evidence that this person might be wrong, that in fact that I might be better than they, than they think I am." Samir Nurmohamed: Yeah, absolutely. So for example, there are these really cool studies asking people, you know, "Are you better than the average driver in this room?" And, you know, 80% of the, the room go, has their hands go up, showing that, you know, they're, they're better drivers, which of course cannot be true if you're better than average. And then you have something similar, you know, in other domains. So for example, when it comes to morality and honesty, people think that they're more honest than others, and these all relate to this self-enhancement bias that we have. SHANKAR VEDANTAM: I'm wondering if you can walk me through some of the research, Samir, that, that you did, that in some ways made the case that self-enhancement theory or reactance was at work in, in driving the underdog effect. Samir Nurmohamed: So after these findings in the field within a company, I went into the lab to basically find out, you know, how do people respond to these different sets of expectations. So in one study, um, participants were in a negotiating task, and what we did is we gave people an assessment of how well they would do in a negotiation. And unbeknownst to the participants themselves, after completing that assessment they were told that researchers either expected them to do well, to be the favorite or do poorly, to be the underdog. SHANKAR VEDANTAM: Hmm. Samir Nurmohamed: And then we had them go into a, a negotiation. And what we found is that when people were, received the expectations that they were an underdog, they not only performed better in the negotiation, but they actually wanted to prove those researchers wrong, their expectations of them wrong. SHANKAR VEDANTAM: You also make the case that the underdog effect might be activating our fight versus flight motivation. Um, unpack this idea for me, Samir. Samir Nurmohamed: Yeah, so there's this idea of fight or flight or, or challenge versus threat, and I think if you look at those earlier studies on the self-fulfilling prophecy, all of them tended to be about the, the threat response that it evokes, you know. We become less confident in ourselves. Um, we put in less effort, and we perform worse. But in some ways, and you know, what I was hearing in, in talking with people in companies, is that people don't always receive these expectations in that way. Actually, sometimes our am- people are amped up by them. They're challenged by them, and they wanna prove others wrong, and they also wanna surpass others' expectations that they have of themselves. SHANKAR VEDANTAM: Hmm. So instead of flight, you now have fight. Samir Nurmohamed: Absolutely, and I think that's where that reactance component comes in. So it's not that these people are, you know, leaving the company after they're told they can't do well or they're leaving the lab after they're told that researchers don't expect them to succeed in the negotiation. SHANKAR VEDANTAM: Hmm. Samir Nurmohamed: They stay there, and they try to perform better. SHANKAR VEDANTAM: So I'm wondering, is there a contradiction then with the earlier work on the Pygmalion effect, uh, you know, the self-fulfilling prophecy, uh, effect? Or, or is ... Or in some ways, do these two things live side by side, that sometimes negative feedback causes us to pursue flight, and sometimes it causes us to fight? Samir Nurmohamed: Yeah, I was wondering about this myself as a researcher and, you know, how are my findings reconciling what, what had been shown before with the self-fulfilling prophecy. And it was actually through the review process in publishing this article that the editor raised this point to me and really challenged me to try to find, you know, how can you reconcile these two theories. And one of the things that occurred to me is that in that earlier work on the self-fulfilling prophecy is that there are two things that were going on. One is that a lot of the times these expectations came from people who were in authority positions, people like your manager or supervisor, and those people might have more power over you and can shape how you perform. SHANKAR VEDANTAM: Hmm. Samir Nurmohamed: The other thing that stood out was that these people were often more credible. SHANKAR VEDANTAM: Hmm. Samir Nurmohamed: So for example, if you think about a manager, an authority figure, sometimes these people have more expertise or at least more experience than you. Um, but what I was finding in my research was that not everyone that has low expectations of you is seen credibly. SHANKAR VEDANTAM: Right. Samir Nurmohamed: So for example, if you know, you were in that research study in, in the field, you had just entered this company, people may not know you as well, for example, as you know yourself. Similarly in the lab, if you're coming into one of my studies, researchers are giving you this assessment, but they don't know much more about you than that. So there was something different here about the credibility of who holds the expectations, and that might be the key to understanding why I was finding these effects. SHANKAR VEDANTAM: That's fascinating. So what you're saying basically is that when the criticism comes from somebody with high credibility, it might have more of a self-fulfilling prophecy effect, but when the criticism comes from someone who potentially has low credibility, it might prompt us to, to fight back, to disagree with it, to find contrary evidence. Samir Nurmohamed: Yeah, that's exactly right, and that's what I tried to do in, in the last study that I had. So in addition to giving people different sets of expectations, whether they were seen as likely to succeed or less likely to succeed, I varied the credibility of the observers. You know, how accurate were they as forecasters and, you know, whether they were seen as experts or not. SHANKAR VEDANTAM: Hmm. Samir Nurmohamed: And what had ended up happening is that I found that it was only when those observers were seen as less credible by the participant that it translated to higher performance. One example of this was Aly Raisman, who is a, a gymnast for the US Olympic team. Um, after the 2012 Olympics, she had just missed out on placing on the podium. And, you know, for gymnasts, you're often thought, your careers are, are rather short. Um, gymnasts retire rather early in their, in their lives. Um, but Aly Raisman returned for the 2016 Olympics, and was funnily enough, uh, critics started calling her ‘the grandma’ ‘cause she was so much older than other gymnasts. But she famously famously talks about how she used those critics', you know, concerns and perspectives to motivate her through training to try to perform better. SHANKAR VEDANTAM: Being dismissed can make us curl up into a ball and give up, but sometimes, being dismissed makes us rise to the occasion and stand up and fight. Underdogs who have a chip on their shoulder don't perform well in spite of being doubted, they perform well because they've been doubted. When we come back, how we can use the underdog effect to motivate ourselves and the people around us. Also, in our companion episode on Hidden Brain Plus, we explore the role of critical feedback in close relationships. Sometimes the people offering us criticism are not strangers and bosses, but our own friends and family. How should you listen to this feedback, and how can you offer feedback to your children or family members in a way that motivates them, rather than demoralizes them? If you're a subscriber to Hidden Brain Plus, that episode is available right now in your podcast feed. It's titled “What Do They Know?” If you're not yet a subscriber, please consider signing up at support.hiddenbrain.org. If you're using an Apple device, go to apple.co/hiddenbrain. You'll instantly have access to all our subscriber-only content, and your subscription will support all the reporting, writing, and fact-checking that goes into every episode of the show. Again, that's support.hiddenbrain.org or apple.co/hiddenbrain. You're listening to Hidden Brain. I'm Shankar Vedantam. SHANKAR VEDANTAM: This is Hidden Brain. I'm Shankar Vedantam. Can you think of a time when you felt like an underdog? Has a critical comment changed the course of your life for better or for worse? If you have a personal story you'd be willing to share with the Hidden Brain audience, or a question or comment about the research into the underdog effect, please find a very quiet room and record a voice memo on your phone. Two or three minutes is plenty. Email the audio file to us using the email address [email protected]. Use the subject line “underdog.” Again, that's [email protected]. At the University of Pennsylvania's Wharton School, Samir Nurmohamed studies what makes people rise to the occasion. He says that when other people have low expectations of us, this can sometimes motivate us rather than hold us back. He also says there are ways to harness the underdog effect to our advantage. Samir, you cite the example of the basketball player Jalen Brunson as a perfect example of the underdog effect. Tell me his story, and for our non-sports fan listeners, perhaps start by explaining who Jalen Brunson is. Samir Nurmohamed: Yeah. So Jalen Brunson was a player who actually played for Villanova and won a national championship with them as a basketball player. And then he was drafted by the Dallas Mavericks. Um, but was, you know, kinda like Tom Brady drafted in the second round, not sixth round at least. Um, but there were many other guards that were drafted over him. And he started having a really good career in the NBA, but when it came time to re-sign with the Dallas Mavericks, they didn't wanna pay him the same amount as some of the other teams. So the New York Knicks ended up, um, getting Jalen Brunson, and at the time many people thought this was a terrible signing. SHANKAR VEDANTAM: Hmm. Samir Nurmohamed: So people thought, you know, he wouldn't be the type of player that the Knicks needed to win them a championship, and he wouldn't even make the team much better. SHANKAR VEDANTAM: Now, of course, we're recording this interview a few weeks after the Knicks won the NBA championship, with Jalen Brunson at the helm. Samir Nurmohamed: Absolutely. So, you know, uh, y- for, for someone like John Hollinger from The Athletic who said Jalen Brunson was the wrong player at the wrong moment for New York couldn't be further from the truth. Um, Brunson ended up being incredibly successful, started having longer runs in the playoffs with the New York Knicks, and then famously won, uh, the title with the Knicks and, and won the MVP trophy. SHANKAR VEDANTAM: I understand that Jalen Brunson, very much like Tom Brady, deliberately used the underdog effect to motivate himself. Samir Nurmohamed: He talks about these experiences for motivating himself in the gym, you know, off the court in terms of practicing, um, for trying to address some of the skills that, you know, he wasn't as strong in. So he continues to use these quotes over, over the years, even when people now have awarded him the MVP trophy, he still thinks of himself not as a star. Um, and even in, you know, after he won the championship, people were asking about the extent to which he proved others wrong, and he was, like, basically nonchalant about it. He's like, "Yeah, I use this to, to fuel me." SHANKAR VEDANTAM: So we talked earlier about Tom Brady's underdog story, Samir. Um, his coach at the New England Patriots, Bill Belichick, regularly used the underdog effect to motivate his players. I want to play you a clip from Tom Brady's former teammate, uh, Damien Woody, talking about how the coach would highlight what critics said about the team. Damien Woody: Granted, there were so many times I would have to come in in the morning for workouts and stuff like that, and Bill would be on the StairMaster and would have a huge clip of papers and all those type of things, and he would be working out and highlighting everything that everyone was saying in the media. And he would be telling us and showing us, uh, during our meetings and the night before the game. So when you hear people up in New England say they don't, they ignoring the noise, trust me, no, they are paying attention to everything that we have to say. That's fascinating. Now, don't ignore the noise, use the noise. Use it to your benefit. SHANKAR VEDANTAM: in some ways that's, that's exactly what you're talking about here, isn't it, Samir? Samir Nurmohamed: Yeah, in many ways, you know, the way that you use bulletin board material or what other people say about you as a rallying cry, um, there's been a little less research done on this exact topic. But, you know, many people talk about how it can build unity among a team, especially when people outside of your team are doubting you. So Naomi Ellemers, for example, has done this research showing that people are more likely to identify with a group or team- SHANKAR VEDANTAM: Hmm ... Samir Nurmohamed: when there's external circumstances that threaten their success. And I think you can take some of that bulletin board material as a case in point for that. SHANKAR VEDANTAM: Now, it's one thing for us to use negative feedback as a source of motivation, but when we are offering feedback to others, I can see such criticism as being potentially dangerous. How do we know when critical feedback is going to fire someone up or end up crushing their spirit? Samir Nurmohamed: I think that's really the, the careful thread and the tightrope that a lot of people have to walk when they're doing this. I think that's one of the things that great coaches figure out. They figure out, okay, which players will really be amped up by this versus which players, you know, might not respond to this in the same way. And one of the things that I've been- become more curious about is the extent to which, you know, you have an established relationship with that person, or you have trust built in with that person. I think that makes a difference in terms of how it lands. SHANKAR VEDANTAM: Do you think there are personality differences that might be important in how we respond to barbs and rejection, Samir? Samir Nurmohamed: I think so. I haven't found as much of it in, in my research, but there is this, boundary condition to my research, which is that people have to have some requisite level of confidence in themselves and also skills and abilities to respond favorably to this. So for example, you know, I'm not a golfer at all, and if you told me that I'm not gonna golf well and so forth, that's not gonna be as motivating to me versus you telling me that about something that I have more experience and more expertise in and more confidence about. SHANKAR VEDANTAM: You once studied the underdog phenomenon looking at job seekers who had experienced discrimination. Describe the study for me, Samir, and tell me what you found. Samir Nurmohamed: Yeah. So one of the things that came out of my research on the underdog effect was thinking about, okay, well, how can we use this to motivate people and improve people's circumstances? So I was doing some research with re-employment centers, and when I was presenting to the board, they actually asked me, you know, "How can we use some of your research to address some of the challenges that we're facing?" And I realized that this would be a ripe opportunity for doing what's called a field intervention. SHANKAR VEDANTAM: Hmm. Samir Nurmohamed: So what we ended up doing was running these workshops with job seekers in which we had them form narratives and stories from their lives. Um, but what we ended up doing is that we gave different job seekers, we randomly assigned them to different treatments. so in one of the in- interventions, which we call the favorite intervention, the high expectations intervention, we had people tell stories about a time in their life when other people believed in them, and they also believed in themselves, and they ended up being successful. But in another intervention, we had them form what we called an underdog narrative, and these were times in which other people didn't believe they could succeed, but they defied those low expectations and ended up being successful. so we had people think of stories like this from their lives, and we also had them reflect on those experiences, what lessons did they learn, what themes came up from it, and how they would apply that to their own job search going forward. SHANKAR VEDANTAM: And what did you find? Samir Nurmohamed: So what we found was really interesting. So we did these one-hour long interventions, these workshops, and what we found is that when people had the underdog narrative, what it did is it buffered them against experiences of adversity in the form of discrimination. SHANKAR VEDANTAM: Hmm. Samir Nurmohamed: And what ended up happening is that this adversity didn't impact themselves as negatively. So it actually buffered them against their drop in self-confidence in the job search. And weeks later, what we found is that these people were more likely to get jobs, essentially. SHANKAR VEDANTAM: Hmm. In other words, uh, triggering the underdog effect almost was inoculating people against the effects of discrimination. Samir Nurmohamed: Yeah, absolutely. And that's, you know, we did this in the field in these reemployment centers, and then we did some follow-up studies to better understand what was going on, and we saw this consistent finding across different settings. SHANKAR VEDANTAM: Hmm. You also have looked at some fascinating work when people are selected for something, but then they later discover that they were not the first choice. Uh, tell me about this work, Samir. Samir Nurmohamed: This is something that, you know, came out of personal experiences that I had, but other people have also had, is that, you know, you're, you're chosen for a role, whether it's in a company or a job, but you find out later, you discover that you weren't the first choice for the role, that they actually had someone else in mind, but that person ended up going somewhere else, so they chose you for the position. And it has a very similar feel to this underdog flavor that we've been talking about, these underdog expectations. And what I was curious about in this research is how does being an alternate choice affect you when you start your job, when you start in that role? SHANKAR VEDANTAM: Hmm. Samir Nurmohamed: And one of the things that I found is that when you're the alternate choice, although I find these positive effects for being the underdog, it doesn't always translate to the most positive things at work. So for example, what we found in this research is that it led to people seeking less feedback from others in their jobs. And as we did further studies, the, the underlying reason that we found, this was a study that I did with Zoe Schwingel Sauer is what we found is that people felt less integrated into their group socially. Hmm. So they felt less comfortable in their group when they were the alternate choice, and that probably prohibited them from seeking feedback as much as they should have. SHANKAR VEDANTAM: So again, I'm wondering what explains someone like Tom Brady, given what you just told me. I mean, in the 2000 NFL Draft, there were six quarterbacks taken before him. So he wasn't the second choice or, or even the third choice or the fourth choice. He was the seventh choice when it came to quarterback. Um, how do you think he overcame it? Samir Nurmohamed: I think that's a really interesting question, and I'm, I'm still trying to sort that out for myself in the research, honestly. Um, I do think that there's something about these expectations that you experience at different points in your life- SHANKAR VEDANTAM: Yeah ... Samir Nurmohamed: and them giving you these developmental opportunities to, to get better. But I, but I'm still trying to unpack that as a researcher. SHANKAR VEDANTAM: Yeah, it's also possible that he's a unicorn and, and an N of one. Samir Nurmohamed: That he might be a unicorn, yeah. And I think that's one of the things that I'm trying to figure out in my own work, you know, how... A lot of people will ask, "Is this just a personality trait, or is there something broader?" I think my work would say that it's not just a personality trait, but, um, there are these contingencies there. SHANKAR VEDANTAM: You say that one way we can use the underdog narrative as a motivator to build self-confidence is to identify the skills that we need to be successful. Unpack that idea for me. Samir Nurmohamed: One of the things that, you know, comes out of, of research, you know, so there's this famous, uh, finding of the Dunning-Kruger effect. And, you know, that's, that study's all about showing that people who are unskilled at something sometimes have the most inflated self-assessments of themselves because they're unaware about how incompetent they may actually be. So, you know, if I'm a bad golfer, I may know that I'm bad, but I don't realize how bad I am. SHANKAR VEDANTAM: Mm-hmm. Samir Nurmohamed: Um, so one of the things that we need to do as underdogs is figure out, okay, well, what weaknesses do we have and what can we get better at? But rather than just relying on ourselves, we should also go to other people in our environment, uh, the other people around us who know us well. But what I would say is not just focus on our weaknesses, but also figure out and have them tell us about our strengths that we may, we may not actually see. So there's been this really cool exercise done by researchers at the University of Michigan, uh, called the reflected best self exercise, in which people go to others, people in their network, even those outside of work, to better understand their core strengths. And the idea is that getting feedback from other people in your life will allow you to better understand the skills that you bring to the table. SHANKAR VEDANTAM: A reminder, can you think of a time when you felt like an underdog? Has a critical comment changed the course of your life, for better or for worse? If you have a personal story you'd be willing to share with the Hidden Brain audience, or a question or comment about the research into the underdog effect, please find a very quiet room and record a voice memo on your phone. Two or three minutes is plenty. Email the audio file to us using the email address [email protected]. Use the subject line “underdog.” Again, that's [email protected]. SHANKAR VEDANTAM: We talked earlier about the hinge that credibility offers, that when the criticism comes from somebody who is highly credible, we're likely to absorb that criticism. When the criticism comes from someone who is not credible, we're more likely to have the underdog effect, uh, triggered in us. Talk about whether we can use this to our advantage when it comes to deploying the underdog effect, Samir. Samir Nurmohamed: I think you can use credibility to your advantage. So credibility, just like underdog expectations, is subjective. And one of the things we can think about, whether it's for ourselves or for the teams that we lead or manage, is thinking about, well, who has these expectations? And are these people credible or not? And one thing to think about is: What's the track record of this person? You know, are they always right? Or quite often, more often than not, they're, you know, they're not always right, so spotlighting those experiences for both ourselves and our team. SHANKAR VEDANTAM: Hmm. Samir Nurmohamed: But also thinking about the assessment that they're using to come up with the underdog expectations themselves. What gaps or blind spots might that assessment have? What are they not accounting for? What strengths do they not see, for example? And that might be another way to poke holes in the credibility of not only the forecaster but also the assessment being used. SHANKAR VEDANTAM: So in some ways in the Tom Brady story, you know, perhaps he may have said to himself, "You know, yes, the criticisms of me, uh, in terms of my physicality might, might be accurate, but what, what the scouting report is missing are all the intangibles that, that are not showing up in arm strength and throwing ability." Samir Nurmohamed: Yeah, absolutely. You know, thinking about, well, you know, are these the things that actually make a strong quarterback? Does everyone have to have the exact same physique or the best physical vertical jump? So that might be one part. The second part is thinking about, well, can I actually get better at some of these things? So, you know, height might be more set in stone, but there are other things that I can work on and get better at, right? So Tom Brady was famous for, you know, spending a lot of time on the field, not only during practice but after practice, watching video and film to gain a competitive advantage against other teams, and there were other people in his corner that were helping him do that, and he really tried to bring that to the table. And of course, some of the critics didn't see all of that, especially when he was playing. SHANKAR VEDANTAM: I'm curious how the underdog effect translates to group accomplishments, Samir. Uh, you talk about a famous hockey game that took place on February 22nd, 1980. Tell me that story. Samir Nurmohamed: Yeah, so this was, you know, the US Olympic team, um, in the '80s. They were filled by a group of amateur hockey players, and at the time, this was at the height of the Cold War, and they were going up against the USSR. And in this game, uh, the Americans were basically written off and thought to... they would get creamed, essentially, by the Soviet Union, and this was became known as the Miracle on Ice, in which the US Olympic team ended up winning the game and ended up winning the gold medal in the 1980 Olympics. SHANKAR VEDANTAM: So I'm, I'm wondering, are there larger lessons that groups can draw in, in this situation, not just in, in the, in the context of sports, but maybe a- as communities, as, as cities, as, as even as nations? Samir Nurmohamed: Yeah, I think one of the big lessons from, from this is that others' expectations don't dictate our success or performance. And I think one of the interesting things about being in a group, unlike an individual, is that when you're an underdog as an individual, it can sometimes be a very lonely experience, um, 'cause you're the only one going through that adversity yourself. As a group, it can still be lonely, but at least you have others that you can lean on. Um, and I'm reminded of a time in which, you know, I was doing this work in a company, and I was talking to an executive, and he talked about, for example, at his company, that he put together a ragtag team of, of people who the company thought were a bunch of dinosaurs, essentially, and they would never perform in the same way. SHANKAR VEDANTAM: Hmm. Samir Nurmohamed: But they kinda had this common theme that everyone had written them off, not only 'cause they were, you know, out of sync with the rest of the company, but because they were older, essentially. SHANKAR VEDANTAM: Hmm. Samir Nurmohamed: But as a group, they kind of used that as a rallying cry to, to be motivated by others' expectations and lean on each other and learn from each other. And that ended up motivating them to be more successful. SHANKAR VEDANTAM: I'm wondering, given all of this research, Samir, whether you go actively searching for slights and criticism to give yourself a motivational boost? Samir Nurmohamed: I don't know if I still-- I think I did that when I was younger, but maybe not to the same day. But I think this is baked in a lot of us. You know, there ... For example, as a, as a faculty member, you know, when I teach, I get my evaluations at the end of the semester, and even when they, the course goes really well, I'll focus on those one or two pieces of criticism, and sometimes I'll use that to rev me up for the, for the next semester. Um, you know, the other example is, is at home I have this funny thing with my kids. I don't, I don't constantly go around making them the underdogs at all. But I'll do it in a funny and joking way with my son, who's now turning seven. You know, I'll say, "I don't think you can do this. I don't think you can pull it off." But just the way, the tone of voice that I do it in, he knows that I'm kinda joking and it's kind of a challenge. So it's not resulting in flight, it's resulting in fight. SHANKAR VEDANTAM: Samir Nurmohamed is an organizational scientist at the University of Pennsylvania's Wharton School. Samir, thank you so much for joining me today on Hidden Brain. Samir Nurmohamed: It was a pleasure to have this conversation with you, Shankar. Thanks so much for having me. Samir's research suggests that when we're doubted by others, we can turn that doubt into a dare. We can challenge ourselves to stretch outside our comfort zone, prove the naysayers wrong. We can turn our underdog story into a hero's journey. Stories in which characters transform from underdogs into heroes show up again and again across different times and cultures. These stories often follow a certain pattern. A person is called to a challenge. Suffering follows, sometimes many years of it. Finally, our protagonist succeeds and is lauded as a hero. Think of the biblical story of David battling Goliath, or in modern times, of Spider-Man leaping across skyscrapers and bridges to take on villains of great cunning and strength. What makes these stories so enduringly powerful? What can they teach us about our own lives? When we come back, we explore these questions with researcher Ben Rogers, and listeners share their own journeys to recognizing the hero in themselves. You're listening to Hidden Brain. I'm Shankar Vedantam. This is Hidden Brain. I'm Shankar Vedantam. If someone asked you to author the definitive autobiography of your life, what would you write? Perhaps you'd detail a list of your achievements or experiences you've had, the people you've known. Would there be a theme to your life story? A grand theory of what makes you, you? When we tell the stories of our lives, we form a certain narrative in our minds. It turns out, how these stories are told can have profound implications. We explored this topic on two recent episodes of Hidden Brain, titled “You Are Not Ordinary” and “How to Discover Your Inner Hero.” Our guide was Ben Rogers, a social scientist at Boston College. Today, Ben is back on the show to answer your questions about his research. Ben Rogers, welcome back to Hidden Brain. Ben Rogers: Hi, Shankar. Thanks for having me back. SHANKAR VEDANTAM: So Ben, let's start at the 30,000-foot level. Um, very often when we think about the events that happen in our lives, we think, you know, A happened and then B happened and then C happened, but we don't often consider how the storytelling that links those events together actually matters. Why is it that that storytelling is important? Ben Rogers: So if you dig into the literature on meaning and, and sense-making, how we make sense of our lives, you know, we're all constantly telling ourselves stories about our experiences, and we're often not conscious of the stories that we're telling. We kind of connect the dots in whatever way feels natural or makes sense. But there's a lot of research that has shown that the way in which we tell those stories or the types of stories seems to associate to positive things. And in the work that we have looked at, we wanted to see if you change the story or if you adjust the story in some way, might it have similar types of effects, you know, taking a little bit of agency over the way in which you're telling your story. SHANKAR VEDANTAM: So in our last conversation, we talked about a framework of storytelling called the Hero's Journey. What is the Hero's Journey, Ben? Ben Rogers: The Hero's Journey is a narrative framework that was discovered or sort of put together by Joseph Campbell, who's a mythologist, and he was looking at narratives across thousands of years of history across the globe, uh, a lot of variation in terms of myths and religious texts. And what he saw was across all of these different enduring narratives was a similar pattern, a similar type of plot that seemed to follow different elements. And while the specifics of the narrative might vary, the same underlying things seem to be happening no matter the type of story. SHANKAR VEDANTAM: And what are some of the elements of this Hero's Journey? Ben Rogers: In Joseph Campbell's version, I think there was about 17 steps. In the work that we've done, we boiled it down to seven key elements. In summarizing that very briefly, it's a hero, often an unknown, uh, ordinary hero or a protagonist. They experience some sort of change of setting, which we call a shift of life circumstances, and that sets them off on some sort of quest or mission of some sort, and during which they encounter friends and allies of various types, and they also face obstacles or challenges, whether that's external or internal. But as a result of facing those challenges, they end up transforming in some way, whether fantastical or developing some keen inner insight, and after that transformation, they return home to benefit others and leave a legacy of some sort. SHANKAR VEDANTAM: So we heard from a number of listeners who shared their own stories of their hero's journey. Um, here is one from Jeff. Jeff: I used to be a full-time dairy farmer. It's a very difficult time in our country to be a small dairy farmer, and about four years ago, in the spring of 2022, I made the very difficult and painful decision to shut down the dairy, which meant having to sell our beloved and beautiful Guernsey dairy cows. This absolutely broke my heart and caused me to spiral down into a depression, and in the midst of that heartache and pain, um, I ended up turning to an old friend for comfort and relief, and that was my guitar. I had always messed around with, uh, writing songs, playing guitar and writing songs, and I knew that I had to get all those pent-up emotions out. So I, um, went down to the barn, uh, where the cows used to be, and it was totally empty, and I ended up channeling from the ether, uh, this song called “Empty Barn.” At the time, I was 55 years old. I had never released any music on the Internet. Just put up a guitar vocal recording of this song, “Empty Barn,” and all on its own, um, that little recording went viral. And I started getting asked to do performances and particularly speaking engagements to tell my story on the subject of farmer mental health. Fast forward now, we're four years later. I have a full-time career as an independent music artist and speaker. And many, many people comment how much my music and my story means to them, how it impacted them, how it helped them deal with their own pain of loss, how my story and my music gives voice to other farmers who are going through similar things. So thank you guys so much for this wonderful podcast, and thank you for giving me the opportunity to do this. Farmer out. SHANKAR VEDANTAM: So Ben, um, Jeff's story strikes me as a classic, uh, hero's journey. Uh, what are some of the hallmarks of the hero's journey that you hear in the story? Ben Rogers: Absolutely, I think that the way that it lined up was actually so remarkable of, um, you know, you think of the protagonist and often unknown, so you know, Jeff began as a dairy farmer, faced some challenging circumstances in terms of the, you know, macroeconomic circumstances not being as relevant, and obviously faced some intense challenges. Had to shut down the dairy farm and deal with mental health issues, so both challenges external and internal. Uh, what was interesting I think that also stuck out to me was the ally was maybe not what you think of as the traditional, you know, ally, like a, a wizard or a mentor of some sort. It was a guitar, an inanimate object. But what I love is that he uses this challenge to transform in a very powerful way, in a way that didn't seem like he expected, but sort of set off his life in a very different way. And I love how he's used this newfound skill or, or path in life to give back to the broader community. And so, you know, I don't think I could've scripted it better myself to hit those seven elements. SHANKAR VEDANTAM: Yeah. So the exciting and freeing part of storytelling is that it's an action. We can decide how to shape the narrative, when to start and stop the story, and also decide what the central lesson is at the core of the story. A listener, Michelle, called in with an experience about making that choice. Michelle 2: So 2016 was a big year of change for me. I resigned from a company I'd worked for for 15 years, my first jobs after graduation. Then I ended a long-term relationship after 19 years. And to complete the trifecta, I moved away from the city I'd lived in from, for more than 20 years to return to my hometown. It was a lot, and talking to people, whether they be old friends or new acquaintances, I found I needed a narrative to explain all this change to them, and also to understand for myself. At first, I called it a midlife crisis. I was blowing up a perfectly good life because I was nearly 40 years old and needed a change. I found this narrative totally unsatisfying. It drained the meaning out of these big life events, turning them into a tired trope, and I put it aside. Later, I framed things as overcoming adversity, that I was picking up the pieces after a divorce and establishing a new life for myself. Though easy to understand and better than the previous narrative, it started to fall apart as the years passed and there were no notable victories in my life, and I started experiencing some issues with my mental health, and it too got put aside. But sometime in the last couple of years, I started to see things quite differently, that I was finally becoming the main character in my own life, no longer just a supporting character in other people's stories. What I like about this narrative is that I can integrate more parts of my life into it. Um, the humble start, you know, as a secondary character. The moment of shift, which in my case was being a contestant on the game show Jeopardy. The point of no return with my work and my personal relationships, and, and even my mental health challenges. It, it, it all helps to frame my life with its ups and downs as a journey in personal growth. And now, now that I've learned that this narrative framework can be called the hero's journey, it gives it even more meaning. It helps me see my old life in a different way too, that it's not just the burdensome past to overcome, but it's a hero's backstory, uh, perhaps even worthy of a prequel. SHANKAR VEDANTAM: So Ben, what I find fascinating about Michelle's message is how coming up with the frame of a hero's journey can render events that might otherwise be mundane or sad as merely the setup, the, the prequel, as Michelle calls it, to the main event. Ben Rogers: Yeah, I think that's fascinating. And you know, there's lots of psychological research on the ways in which we get caught up in our day-to-day experiences. We get caught up in either the drudgery or the challenge or the unpleasantness, and we're not often given an excuse or, or a framework or a permission structure to see our lives a little bit differently. You know, I think she identified seeing herself as the main character in her story or a main character. And it's not to overly emphasize yourself as the star of the universe, but to realize we are the main characters of our own journeys, and all of our journeys are heroic or meaningful in different ways, and figuring out how do we identify those elements, but also how do we connect them in a way that both makes sense but also feels meaningful to us. The team and I have collected thousands of stories from people across our studies, and the stories really range in terms of the, uh, immensity of the challenges that people faced, whether it was things like going to prison or having loved ones die at an early age, to things like going off to college and being unsure of oneself or starting a new job and not being sure. You know, all of these stories people were able to tell in terms of a really heroic lens about themselves, 'cause we're all facing different challenges, we're all facing different things. And so it's not about comparing whose life is more heroic, it's thinking about, does your life feel heroic to yourself and, uh, how can you sort of help coax yourself along the way to see your life in that manner. SHANKAR VEDANTAM: One subtext to Michelle's story is that sometimes the stories we tell about our lives, uh, shift as the events shift. Uh, so we graduate from school, we enter a new romantic relationship, we move to a new city. All of these can constitute major plot points that can change the narrative. Listener Tony spent 20 years in the US Army deploying around the world. It was a role that gave him a very clear narrative to embrace. Tony: I learned to accept the mission, carry the weight, and keep moving forward. When I was asked to jump, the reply, the automatic reply was, "How high?" I believe that the hero was the person, the soldier, the officer who could endure more, carry more, and remain strong regardless of what was happening internally. The most challenging transition came when I prepared to leave the Army. After decades of having a clear identity, a clear mission, clear structure, I had to confront the question that felt more difficult than many of the missions that I had faced. Who am I without a uniform, without the structure? Being coached and then becoming a coach helped me recognize that a hero's journey does not always require conquering an external challenge. Sometimes the real journey is inward. This narrative absolutely continues to shape my work as a coach. I help people examine their stories they have inherited from others about strength, identity, achievement, and service, and then I often ask them a question that I had to ask myself, is this still your story? Or, or is it simply a story that once helped you survive for a time? So this is fascinating, Ben. What serves you as a hero's journey story at one point in your life might not serve you as a hero's journey story in another point of your life. Ben Rogers: Yeah, I think that's a fascinating insight and, and one I've also grappled with in terms of this work. So in the hero's journey paper that, uh, the team and I worked on, we very much were thinking about your life up until now. But if you think about it, uh, life is full of ups and downs and different arcs, and there can be the hero's journey of your early adulthood, and then something happens, and maybe that sets off another hero's journey. And I think there's some nervousness that might come about of thinking of how subjective our life stories are that might feel like we're all standing on, uh, shifting sands. But I also think that there's a power to it, of realizing that we can connect the dots of our personal narratives in whatever ways that feel authentic and feel true to ourselves. And so as long as you're revising that and thinking about, "Does this story still suit me? And if not, what is the way that the story that I wanna tell or the story I can tell based on my experiences?" There's a lot of power that can be gained from that. Hmm. Is there something inauthentic about coming up with a story to fit our life situation, Ben? I mean, you know, if, if we can select our stories and then change them when we need to change them, are the stories we tell nothing more than, you know, cloaks or clothes that we put on and take off? I think there, there, that can very much happen, particularly if we're telling the stories that we think other people wanna hear, uh, whether that's for impression management reasons or alternative, that if we're telling stories that are just highlighting very specific elements of our life but are not sort of reflective of our general experiences, that might get you through a short-term experience. But I think over time, I would argue that based on the, you know, narrative literature, that that will not hold or be very effective over time. What will be more effective is reflecting back on what are my experiences, what has felt meaningful to me, and how might those things interrelate, such that you're developing a narrative that, yes, maybe is connecting the framework and the elements in ways that you know are gonna be positive, but that actually feel like they reflect your life in both a true way but a meaningful way. SHANKAR VEDANTAM: When we come back, is there a difference between a hero's journey and a heroine's journey? You're listening to Hidden Brain. I'm Shankar Vedantam. This is Hidden Brain. I'm Shankar Vedantam. How do people narrate the story of their own lives? And what happens when they start to see themselves not as a passive character coasting through life, but as the hero of their own unfolding story? At Boston College, Ben Rogers digs into the elements of the hero's journey, the life shift that sets things in motion, the quest that follows, the allies who show up, the challenges that test us, and the transformation in the end. Ben, before the break, we heard from a listener named Tony who shared his struggle moving from the Army to civilian life. Part of his transition centered on shifting the messaging he received from being a hero in the military to being a hero in daily life, in civilian life. I'm wondering how the institutions in our society shape the image of who is and who is not a hero. Ben Rogers: That's a fascinating question, and as someone who, uh, sits in a business school, I think a lot about the way that organizations and institutions influence the stories that we tell. And I think they really set the context within which we understand ourselves, and I'm talking both about our immediate organizations, whether that's our work, our religion, our, you know, whatever community organizations you're a part of. But I also think on a national level, there's really fascinating work on sort of the national narratives or the cultural narratives that really influence us, and that's something that I like to pursue in my work, is figuring out how is our interplay of our individual narratives and the narratives that we're kind of drawing from as we go about our life, whether drawing from those consciously or subconsciously. So I think we're absolutely influenced – those narratives both give us the material that we can draw from, which can be positive, but they can also be kind of limiting, if you’re thinking of your life story in a way that’s counter-normative or in a way that’s different from what people expect, it can be a little harder to sustain that narrative from a social-psychological perspective. SHANKAR VEDANTAM: Hmm. Now, gender can play a role in how hero's journeys unfold. Uh, men and women are often portrayed as heroes in very different ways. Here is listener Michelle with a comment about that. Michelle: I think what was sparked most for me about this conversation then ended up being wondering what the parallel is for women. Um, what's the heroine's journey? And I think I'm asking because if there isn't one, and then there probably should be one. Um, and at the same time, as I was starting to think about, what are those journeys for women, I don't know that there's any literature that is similar to the patterns of literature that there are about male heroes. I'm gonna make a wild guess that, um, it- it's much more difficult to, quote, unquote, "pin down" a heroine's journey as compared to a hero's journey. I guess if I had a question to ask the author, it would be, is there anything that you can say about the difference between men and women vis-à-vis a, a journey like this?" Anyway, thanks for listening. SHANKAR VEDANTAM: What do you think, Ben? Ben Rogers: It's a great question, and it's one we grappled with 'cause I think, uh, you know, as the listener was saying, if you look historically, I think hero's journeys were often masculine-type narrative, uh, with, you know, male heroes. That was sort of the predominant template for it. I think in recent times that has, uh, changed, thankfully. You know, I can think of Katniss Everdeen from The Hunger Games, that's a story ver- very much centered on a female character, and it, to me, it follows the exact plot line of a hero's journey. And so that was something where, you know, as a social psychologist, we're always thinking about what are the boundary conditions, who does this apply to, and who does this not? And so we, across our studies, looked at to the extent to which, um, in the early studies, are people, are men more likely to see their life as a hero's journey than women? And then when, once we got to the intervention, is our intervention more successful for one gender versus the other? And I think what we can say is, in terms of who's naturally more likely to see their life as a hero's journey, I probably would've implicitly expected that it would be men, but we actually found no discernible difference between, uh, men and women in terms of naturally either seeing their life as a hero's journey or telling their life as a hero's journey. And then in terms of the interventions, we did not see any discernible difference between the efficacy of the intervention. Both men and women were likely to, uh, experience a meaning in life boost and other wellbeing benefits as a result of receiving the intervention. And so I think there is definitely some cultural distinctions to this. But in terms of the evidence we saw, uh, I would say we were pleased to find that our intervention and the benefits of a hero's journey seem to apply equally. SHANKAR VEDANTAM: Hmm. So, so far, Ben, we've talked about seeing ourselves as the hero in our own stories. Uh, but several listeners said that they'd experienced other people as being heroes in their lives. Here's listener Phil with one such story. Phil: I never saw myself as a hero, but I've found many heroes. I was the third of eleven children and never really stood out. I worked for the state government for nearly twenty years, but in both, both parish ministry and government work, I was continually awed by the people around me. I found heroes in unexpected places, in the confessional, in the parish community, as coworkers and bosses in state government. I continually found awesome people who inspired me even on bad days. And I can't say I'm a hero, but I'm certainly glad that I found the heroes I have. SHANKAR VEDANTAM: So Ben, you talked about the value of us seeing ourselves as the protagonists of our own stories, as the heroes in our own journeys. Is it also valuable for us to see other people as heroes in our lives? Ben Rogers: I think so. While I, I don't have direct empirical evidence about that, you know, I feel like the, uh, the consistency of our effects would very much extend that if you're able to find your own experience as more meaningful, then if another person's story felt like it followed a hero's journey to you, you would find that story more meaningful as well. And there's some, uh, work that I've always been inspired by, where they, the authors theorize that the way we tell our story, I tell my story to you, and Shankar, you either nod along encouragingly or maybe you shake your head if the way I'm telling it isn't very good. Hmm. And that's gonna help me revise my story and realize in which way should I tell my story. And so we're social animals, both in terms of the stories that we listen to, but the way in which we tell ours to other people. And so I really like this idea that we're seeing not only our own life stories as something we're maintaining and focused on, but that we're focused on what is my perspective of how my colleagues or my coworkers or my family journeys are as well. That's an idea I've wanted to pursue in research to see if I tell my life story in a certain way, is that gonna encourage people to wanna be allies on my journey and offer me social support or mentorship or other types of things? SHANKAR VEDANTAM: Hmm. I mean, I'm thinking about inspiring leaders like, you know, Martin Luther King Jr. or Nelson Mandela or Mahatma Gandhi. You know, th- they clearly lived heroes' journeys in their own lives, but, but it's also true that millions of people found their journeys inspiring, and it gave all of those followers their lives meaning as well. Ben Rogers: Yeah. Feeling part of a broader movement, and particularly having someone at the head of it whose life story you feel connected to and that you can understand and be inspired by, that can be a very motivating force for people to want to join a movement and to help identify with it. We want to identify with our leaders, and it makes a lot of sense that if our leaders are telling very compelling stories and hopefully authentic and true stories, that we're gonna want to identify with them and see if, you know, I can be part of their story as well, even in a minor way. SHANKAR VEDANTAM: When we come back, can seeing yourself as a hero be a burden? You're listening to Hidden Brain. I'm Shankar Vedantam. This is Hidden Brain. I'm Shankar Vedantam. Ben Rogers is a social scientist at Boston College. He studies how people tell the story of their own lives. Today, he's answering listener questions about a classic storytelling framework, the Hero's Journey. Ben, at first blush, thinking of ourselves as heroes seems like it would be fun and energizing, but doing so can also come with challenges. Here is listener Alison. Alison: At various stages of my life, whenever I feel like some portion of the journey is kind of coming to a natural end, I have learned the lessons I feel like I need to learn, I find myself looking for kind of the next hurdle in some respects or the next, uh, opportunity for continuing that path, continuing the journey with a new challenge. And I do tend to see those struggles as opportunities for growth and for learning, and I'm curious how your research feeds into that continuation of the path or kind of searching for new obstacles. SHANKAR VEDANTAM: So I'm struck by this question, Ben, because one thing that I think Allison is hinting at is that in the conventional way we understand a hero's journey, you know, there's a triumphal, you know, moment at the end when, when the movie comes to a conclusion or the novel comes to a close and, and we know that everything was worth it, all the struggle has paid off, et cetera. And of course, at that point, the movie ends and the, and the novel ends, and you know, we're not told what happens two chapters after that once people have settled back into their boring lives. And, and I can well see Alison's point, which is that once you've been through one of these journeys, you might have a huge desire to be on that journey again, and could that prompt us then to constantly be looking for new challenges, new obstacles, you know, new mountains to climb, and could that in itself become something of a burden? Ben Rogers: I think absolutely. If, if you're always trying to build into a bigger, more epic, more heroic journey, that could very much be a burden, and I've thought about this in terms of my own, you know, research experiences and my own life experiences, in terms of, you know, all right, I got a PhD and I've started a faculty job, now I need to get on the tenure track. You know, you can think of the hedonic treadmill type of concept where we're always looking to the next thing, and I think if you lean into this narrative framework, which I very much, uh, think about all the time myself, there can be very much of, what's the next story I wanna tell? And you might feel that you have to have very compelling new experiences. You have to face grand new challenges. And so I think if you're thinking about the narrative that you're telling and those elements, it could feel very much like a burden. I wish I had some data or some studies that specifically related to this, but I think the thing that I can connect to most directly is what I've seen when I have run this intervention with my undergraduate students, and one of the pieces of feedback they always provide is, "You know, this seems really exciting, but I'm very early on in my journey, and so I'm a little nervous about what challenges I might face or if I'm gonna be able to leave a legacy." And I'm always reassuring them that this is about how you're piecing the elements and the experiences that you have, and I'm always trying to sort of downplay the idea that they need to have a heroic journey. So it's less about having an objectively heroic journey and more about thinking about how whatever journey you're on is heroic within the circumstances that you are. SHANKAR VEDANTAM: We also heard from several listeners who think that there are some obstacles too big to overcome for a hero's journey narrative. Uh, listener Linda asks, "What if we're trying to save someone else, but they are beyond saving?" Linda: I wondered in the hero's journey, what, what is the result if the, if the hero cannot save the person? If the person is or the, the situation is just not solvable. SHANKAR VEDANTAM: What, what do you think, Ben? Are, are there times when trying to put on the, the, the, the superhero cape, uh, can that make us more keenly aware of how we failed? Ben Rogers: Yes, and, uh, we actually collected a study not directly on what Linda was talking about, but we were similarly curious of, is there a limit to which people are willing to engage in this type of narrative restoring of their lives? And, uh, my PhD advisor, Mike Christian, who was also on the paper, had some prior work on people with chronic pain. And so he raised the idea of, you know, that's a very difficult experience for people to try to live with. You know, there's good days, there are bad days. It's often very random, and so maybe we should try the intervention with that population. We saw that, yes, on average, people who restoried their life as a hero's journey felt like their life was more meaningful, so that we are very excited about. What was interesting, I wouldn't say surprising, but was very interesting, was that was the, the study in which we had the most amount of people just opt out of the intervention. Um, you know, we might have in a given study of three or four hundred people, you know, four or five people that say like, "You know, I see what you're trying to do, but no thank you. That doesn't apply to my life." But in this one, we had, I would say ten to fifteen percent of people just say, "You know, this does not reflect my experience. I don't feel like I've transformed as a result of my journey." Um, you know, "Thank you, researcher. Uh, please go along." And so that was something where I think it was humbling, but it was also really fascinating of on average, we're able to still have these effects, but it does seem like for certain people, either because of that specific day or because of the circumstances of their condition, they were not willing to engage in this type of restorying. And I'm not one to say, you know, this is something that everyone absolutely has to adopt. It needs to feel authentic, but that was a really interesting thing that, you know, Linda's comment brought up for me. SHANKAR VEDANTAM: And, and do you think that, that you had a larger number of people drop out of the intervention because it just felt like it was too much? They were, they were dealing with too much. They didn't feel like heroes. They, they felt like they were not the protagonists of their own story, not the authors of their own story, and asking them to, to be those things just felt like it was too much. Ben Rogers: Absolutely. I think that is my intuition after reading all of their answers, and there's a lot of work that shows that people who have these types of conditions, it takes away a lot of their agency. They don't feel in control of how they feel on a given day, what they're able to do. And echoing some of our conversation earlier, if you don't feel in charge of your own life, it's hard to feel in charge of your own narrative. And I think it was too much too soon. In a lot of our studies, people are rewriting their stories in five to 10 minutes, and so possibly with time and a little bit slower of an intervention, more people could be brought along. But asking some people who are facing really difficult things to immediately re-story and adopt their life, there are limits to that that we're very keenly aware of. SHANKAR VEDANTAM: Hmm. We heard from a listener named Kai who consults with entrepreneurs, um, and she had a question about how to help people see themselves as heroes when they're fighting cultural narratives and stereotypes that tell a very different story Kai: An entrepreneur I worked with entered a business setting that had always made her feel like an outsider. In the past, those rooms had been unfamiliar and intimidating. The language, the expectations, the people in the room, all of it had made her question whether she really belonged there. In a hero's journey story, this is the moment before the hero answers the call. For this entrepreneur, the call was permission to take herself seriously as a business owner, to enter the room as its leader, to claim the identity of entrepreneur and CEO. That entrepreneur later told me that she entered that intimidating setting and stood her ground with more confidence because of what she had learned. The room hadn't changed. The fear hadn't disappeared. But her story about herself had changed enough for her to act. My question is, what helps someone answer the call to lead their own life or business when the story in their head says they don't belong and some of the barriers they face are real? SHANKAR VEDANTAM: What do you think, Ben? Ben Rogers: This is a great question and one that we really thought about, and I think was very much the sort of home base that we were operating from. So the hero's journey is one of these broad cultural narratives, and, um, there's been some really fascinating work by many scholars looking at how what they call master cultural narratives. They're often very limiting, particularly to marginalized communities or people who feel like their lives don't line up with it. So if you feel either from your own perception that you don't align with the popular narratives that are told in your society, or maybe you're told by other people that your life story or you are not allowed to tell the same type of journey, there's a lot of very compelling work that shows how, um, alienating that can be, how isolating that can feel. And it's very easy for us to say that, you know, these elements that are in a hero's journey, having new experiences, having missions, that those apply to anyone's life. But for a lot of reasons, um, and very valid reasons, people might not feel naturally attuned that they can tell their story in that same way. That was one of the goals, one of our quests that we were on with this, uh, paper, was to see, can we broaden this out? Can we make it as relevant to people in terms of particularly the intervention of identifying how these elements really can apply to anyone's life. And in the intervention, we very much took the tact of having people first identify the elements in their life, and then at the end, we showed them their story. So instead of upfront saying, "How are you a hero on a journey?" To which many people might naturally say, you know, "I don't think I'm allowed to think of my life that way. I've never thought of my life that way." Instead, we are having them generate the elements, look at their life story with hopefully the idea of going like, "Huh, I've never really thought about how my life might actually tell this type of heroic arc." And, you know, on average, that seemed to work pretty well. But again, there are very real socio-social psychological forces that can sort of inhibit people from naturally being allowed to do this. SHANKAR VEDANTAM: Hmm. And to go back to the topic of agency that we discussed earlier, I think the, the case that I'm hearing you make is that agency might be good for all of us to have, but it is the case that some of us are gonna have more trouble in some ways, um, seeking out or claiming that agentic life. Uh, whether that's because, you know, our life circumstances have, have rendered us unable to have control over our lives or our, the social expectations and stereotypes around us have made it more difficult for us to exercise that agency. So, so the issue is not so much that agency is a bad thing. Agency is probably always a good thing, but some of us probably, it comes more easily to some of us than it does to others. Ben Rogers: I think so. And I think figuring out how to broaden that scope of agency that people feel like they authentically can write their own story and be in charge of their lives to one degree or another, I think that's a really empowering way to go about things, and is one of my goals as a social scientist to try to give people tools like the Re-Storying Intervention that might help them, at least in a small way, to feel a little more agentic about their life story. SHANKAR VEDANTAM: Hmm. You say that when we are modeling our own lives as a hero's journey, we can intentionally lean into new experiences and frame them as adventures. Why would this be beneficial, Ben? Ben Rogers: That would be beneficial, um, for a number of reasons. So I think one is we often fear new experiences, or we over-anticipate how uncomfortable new experiences are gonna be. I can think of one study that's-- they, uh, randomly assigned people to talk to strangers on a bus or a train, and people assumed it was gonna be horrible. And then when they actually did it, they're like, "Oh, that was actually kinda pleasant. I had a good conversation." And so I think our brains naturally fear change. I think that's one of the reasons why in a lot of hero's journeys you see that refusal of the call. I think that's mirroring our human experience of, "It's new, I don't wanna do it." But that once we actually have it, we find that that's how we gain new skills, that's how we gain new perspectives, and we look back and go, "I'm really glad that happened." And so I think to the extent that you can convince yourself that having new experiences is something that may not be comfortable, but is something that will be enriching of your life, that's something that, uh, people should feel comfortable doing in whatever way they can. SHANKAR VEDANTAM: Can you think of a time in your own life when you have done this recently, Ben? Ben Rogers: What came to mind, uh, as you were just asking that, was a experience actually from my late high school period where I was studying abroad in Spain and, uh, in the north region of the Basque region. And they play this game, they call it pelota. It's like a handball where you hit a ball with a hand. And I was watching a bunch of probably eight, nine-year-olds playing this game. It looked really fun. And, uh, I had a couple friends say, "Oh, you should go do that. That'll-- You know, you look like you're really into it." I'm like, "Well, no, I'm not gonna do that." But they literally forced me, you know, like a good moment of shift. They pushed me into it and I, you know, I was seventeen at the time and I was playing handball with eight or nine-year-olds, and they absolutely crushed me. I lost. I didn't score a single point. But I look back on that experience as I'm so glad I did it. I remember how fun it was and how it was cool to be part of a new culture. But that's something where if I had not been at least in the mindset of I'm gonna be abroad and have new experiences, I might have withdrawn from it. But I'm so glad that I, uh, decided to do it. SHANKAR VEDANTAM: Ben Rogers is a social scientist at Boston College. Ben, thank you so much for joining me today on Hidden Brain. Ben Rogers: Thanks, Shankar. It was a pleasure to be here. SHANKAR VEDANTAM: We also heard today from University of Pennsylvania behavioral scientist Samir Nurmohamed. Hidden Brain is produced by Hidden Brain Media. Our audio production team includes Annie Murphy Paul, Kristin Wong, Laura Kwerel, Ryan Katz, Andrew Chadwick, and Nick Woodbury. Tara Boyle is our executive producer. I'm Hidden Brain's executive editor. Helping people see how they can be the author of their own life story is a profound gift that we can offer to others. If there's someone in your life who would find today's episode to be comforting or thought-provoking, please be our hero and share it with them. Explain how they can find our show on the podcast platform of their choice or at hiddenbrain.org. I'm Shankar Vedantam. See you soon.




